A dissertation defense (called a viva voce, or viva, in the UK and many other countries) is an oral examination in which you present and discuss your thesis with examiners. They ask you to explain your research question, justify your methods, interpret your findings and acknowledge your limitations. To prepare, re-read your thesis, summarize your contribution in a few sentences, practice answering common questions, and know your weaknesses before your examiners point them out.
How it works
In the United States
- A committee of usually three to five faculty members, chaired by your adviser.
- Often begins with a public presentation of 20–45 minutes, followed by questions from the audience.
- Then a closed session with the committee.
- The committee decides whether you pass, often with revisions.
In the United Kingdom
- Usually an internal examiner from your university and an external examiner from another, sometimes with an independent chair.
- Usually private, with no audience.
- Often lasts one to three hours, sometimes longer.
- Usually no formal presentation, although some examiners ask for a short summary at the start.
Practices vary by country and university; check your own regulations. In Australia, for example, PhD theses are often examined in writing without an oral exam.
Possible outcomes
UK outcomes typically include:
- Pass with no corrections (rare);
- Pass with minor corrections, the most common outcome, usually within a few months;
- Major corrections, with a longer deadline;
- Revise and resubmit, often with a second viva;
- a lower degree, such as an MPhil, or a fail, which are uncommon.
In the US, committees usually pass candidates with or without revisions, since a student rarely reaches the defense without the adviser's agreement that the work is ready.
Common questions
About the research overall
- Can you summarize your thesis in a few minutes?
- What is your main contribution to knowledge?
- Why did you choose this topic?
- What would you do differently if you started again?
About the literature and theory
- Which authors or studies most influenced your work?
- Why did you choose this theoretical framework?
- How does your work differ from [a key study in your field]?
About the method
- Why did you choose this method over alternatives?
- How did you select your participants or data?
- How did you make sure your results are valid and reliable?
- What ethical issues did you face?
About the findings
- What is your most important finding?
- Did anything surprise you?
- How do your results compare with previous research?
- Are there alternative explanations for your results?
About limitations and the future
- What are the main limitations of your study?
- How would you extend this research?
- What are the practical implications?
- Will you publish your results?
How to prepare
Weeks before
- Re-read your thesis in full. Note typos and errors to mention if asked.
- Write a one-page summary: question, method, key findings and contribution.
- Know your limitations. Prepare honest answers. See limitations in research.
- Update your reading. Check for important studies published since you submitted.
- Read your examiners' work. It helps you understand their perspective.
Practice
- Ask your supervisor or colleagues for a mock viva or defense.
- Practice answering questions out loud, briefly and clearly.
- If you give a presentation, rehearse it to time.
On the day
- Bring a clean copy of your thesis, with tabs for key sections.
- Listen to each question fully. Pausing to think is fine.
- If you do not understand a question, ask for it to be rephrased.
- Admit what you do not know, and explain how you would find out.
- Defend your choices, but stay open to criticism. Examiners want a discussion, not a fight.
Tips for answering
- Start with the answer, then give the reason.
- Use your thesis: refer to pages, tables and figures.
- Acknowledge, then respond: "That is a fair point; I chose X because..."
- Be concise. Long answers can open new lines of questioning.
After the defense
Most candidates receive corrections. Ask for them in writing, agree a deadline, make each change carefully and keep a list of the changes for your examiners.
Prepare your summary
The free abstract generator can help you draft a short summary of your thesis to practice with. Make sure the final version is in your own words.
Frequently asked questions
How long is a viva or defense?
UK vivas usually last one to three hours. US defenses often last one to two hours, including the presentation.
Can you fail a dissertation defense?
It is possible but uncommon, because supervisors usually only let students submit when the work is ready.
Should I bring my thesis?
Yes. Bring a copy with tabs or notes for quick reference.
How do I handle a question I cannot answer?
Say so honestly, explain what you do know, and suggest how you would find the answer.